| Name | Score | City | Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Llao Llao Hotel & Resort | 88.13 | Bariloche | Argentina |
| Park Tower, Buenos Aires | 83.95 | Buenos Aires | Argentina |
| Caesar Park Buenos Aires | 85.43 | Buenos Aires | Argentina |
| Alvear Palace Hotel | 90.12 | Buenos Aires | Argentina |
| Four Seasons Hotel, Buenos Aires | 87.81 | Buenos Aires | Argentina |
| Park Hyatt, Mendoza | 86.08 | Mendoza | Argentina |
| Turtle Inn | 81.41 | Placencia | Belize |
| Blancaneaux Lodge | 87.27 | San Ignacio | Belize |
| Ritz-Carlton, Santiago | 90.37 | Santiago | Chile |
| Hotel Punta Islita | 81.15 | Guanacaste | Costa Rica |
| Four Seasons Resort Costa Rica at Peninsula Papagayo | 89.24 | Peninsula Papagayo | Costa Rica |
| Los Sueños Marriott Ocean & Golf Resort | 81.23 | Puntarenas | Costa Rica |
| Casa Santo Domingo | 85.20 | La Antigua Guatemala | Guatemala |
| Las Brisas Acapulco | 82.51 | Acapulco | Mexico |
| Las Ventanas al Paraíso | 84.97 | Baja | Mexico |
| One & Only Palmilla | 86.98 | Baja | Mexico |
| Esperanza | 85.57 | Baja | Mexico |
| Ritz-Carlton, Cancun | 85.72 | Cancún | Mexico |
| JW Marriott Cancun Resort & Spa | 82.60 | Cancún | Mexico |
| Las Mañanitas | 85.67 | Cuernavaca | Mexico |
| Royal Hideaway Playacar | 82.29 | Maya Riviera | Mexico |
| Four Seasons Hotel, Mexico D.F. | 82.90 | Mexico City | Mexico |
| Camino Real Oaxaca | 81.94 | Oaxaca | Mexico |
| Four Seasons Resort Punta Mita | 84.14 | Punta Mita | Mexico |
| Casa de Sierra Nevada | 82.02 | San Miguel de Allende | Mexico |
| La Casa Que Canta | 90.20 | Zihuatanejo | Mexico |
| Hotel Monasterio | 88.81 | Cuzco | Peru |
| JW Marriott Hotel, Lima | 81.75 | Lima | Peru |
| Machu Picchu Sanctuary Lodge | 82.64 | Machu Picchu Village | Peru |
| Four Seasons Resort, Carmelo | 90.25 | Carmelo | Uruguay |